|
|
|
|
|
| Minutes
ot the 2002 Annual Business Meeting Legislative Studies Section American Political Science Association The
business meeting of the Legislative Studies Section was held in Boston
during the annual convention of the American Political Science Association. The LSS meeting was convened on Friday,
August 30, 2002 at 5:30 p.m. by Chair David Mayhew of Yale University. The
session began with officers' reports.
Chair Mayhew announced that all the appointments to the prize
committees for this conference had been easily made.
Even though there were fourteen positions to be filled, no
one said no. The chair
offered the floor to outgoing program chair Professor Gary Moncrief
of Boise State University for announcements.
Moncrief indicated that the legislative studies division needs
volunteers to serve as chairs and discussants, especially as discussants
for the poster sessions. He further noted that serving as a poster
discussant does not count against the limit on APSA conference participation.
The Chair then introduced next yearŐs division chair, Professor
Nicol Rae, chair of the Political Science Department at Florida International
University. LSS
Secretary-Treasurer Frances Lee announced that the membership of the
section is holding steady in the 600 range.
Accordingly, the section is financially "in the black,"
and there is no reason to anticipate any problems paying the bills in
the future. In addition, the section was able to sponsor
a reception in honor of its 25th anniversary immediately following the
business meeting. Following
announcements, the session continued with the presentation of awards. Professor Charles M. Cameron of Columbia
University, on behalf of the committee that also included Roger H. Davidson
of University of Maryland and Michael Malbin of University of Albany,
SUNY, presented the Richard F. Fenno, Jr. Prize for the best book on
legislative politics. The
Fenno prize went to Professor Eric Schickler of the University of California
at Berkeley for his book Disjointed Pluralism: Institutional Innovation and the Development of the U.S. Congress
(Princeton University Press).
In his remarks, Cameron indicated that the committee was unanimous
in its selection and encouraged everyone who had not already done so
to read the book. Professor
C. Lawrence Evans, on behalf of the committee that also included John
M. Carey of Washington University and Patricia Hurley of Texas A&M
University. conferred the Congressional Quarterly Press Award for the
best paper presented in the legislative studies division at the 2001
meeting of the APSA The CQ Award went to Kathryn L. Pearson of University
of California, Berkeley for her paper entitled Legislating in Women's
Interests? Congresswomen in the 106th Congress. Professor
Diana Evans of Trinity College, on behalf of the committee that also
included John B. Gilmour of the College of William and Mary and Thomas
F. Remington of Emory University, presented the Carl Albert Dissertation
Award for the best doctoral dissertation in the area of legislative
studies. Deborah Jordan Brooks of the Gallup Organization
received the award for her dissertation entitled "When Candidates
Attack: The Effects of
Negative Campaigning on Voter Turnout in Senate Elections. The
Jewell-Loewenberg Award for the best article published in Legislative
Studies Quarterly went to Professors Stephen Ansolabehere, James
M. Snyder, Jr., and Charles Stewart III, all of the Massachusetts Institute
of Technology, for their article entitled The Effects of Party and
Preferences on Congressional Roll Call Voting, LSQ 26 (November
2001), 533-72. Professor
Ben Bishin of the University of Miami presented the award on behalf
of the committee that also included David Samuels of the University
of Minnesota, Minneapolis and Sarah M. Morehouse, Professor Emerita
of the University of Connecticut.
President Mayhew turned to new business
and yielded the floor to Ken Kurtz of the National Conference of State
Legislatures. Kurtz announced
that the National Conference of State Legislators and the State Legislative
Leaders Association had offered to sponsor and endow a new award named
in honor of Alan Rosenthal. In
the spirit of Rosenthal's work, the purpose of the award is twofold: (1) to recognize the best book or article
in legislative studies of value to legislative practitioners, and (2)
to encourage young scholars to undertake work in this vein. As proposed, the award would be open to
works written in the previous calendar year by authors below the rank
of associate professor. It
would be conferred by an award committee appointed by the LSS President
and one member would be a legislative practitioner.
Anyone, including authors themselves, could offer nominations
to the committee. Discussion of the award followed.
First, a proposal was offered to open the award to scholars of
all ranks by striking the requirement that award recipients be below
the rank of associate professor. The amendment failed on a show of hands,
with 11 voting in favor of the amendment and more than 30 voting against.
Second, a question was raised regarding the eligibility of co-authored
work where one author is above the rank of assistant professor.
It was agreed that such works should be eligible, and the proposal
was amended to reflect that a co-authored publication would be eligible
for the award if at least one of the authors was below the rank of associate
professor. Third, there
was discussion of how to handle works by practitioners. The proposal was amended to clarify that the award was open
to practitioners, provided that they are at a stage in their career
comparable to scholars of junior rank.
Such determinations would be made by the award committee. During the discussion, Professor Bruce
Oppenheimer thanked Karl Kurtz and the National Conference of State
Legislators and the State Legislative Leaders Association for taking
the initiative to sponsor an award.
This suggestion was received with widespread applause. After all concerns had been aired, the
chair put the establishment of the Alan Rosenthal Award to a vote, and
it was adopted unanimously. President
Mayhew then asked Professor Ronald M. Peters, Jr. of the University
of Oklahoma to report on the newsletter. In order to generate the critical mass
necessary to make the LSS listserv succeed, Peters offered a motion
to put all members on the list, with the provision that members could
request that their names be removed.
The motion was agreed to.
He also announced that Professor Burdette Loomis of the University
of Kansas, who has edited the Extension of Remarks since 1996,
had asked that the section begin to consider someone to replace him
as editor. Peters requested
that suggestions be forwarded to him. Finally, Peters followed up on the results
of an inquiry from last year's meeting by announcing that there had
not been sufficient interest to institute a working papers section on
the website. Professor
Linda Fowler suggested that Midwest and APSA papers might be made available
on such a site for longer than they are preserved on the PROceedings
website. Two
other announcements were made.
Professor Barbara Sinclair reminded attendees that the deadline
for paper proposals for the upcoming meeting of the Midwest Political
Science Association is September 15.
Professor David Olson, co-chair of the Research Committee of
Legislative Specialists (RCLS) of the International Political Science
Association, announced that the next RCLS conference will be
held in Durban, South Africa in 2003.
President
Mayhew closed the meeting by inviting everyone to attend the 25th anniversary
reception in the Sheraton Hotel from 6:30 to 8:00. The meeting adjourned at 6:30 p.m. Respectfully
submitted, |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|